It’s a conundrum I’ve yet to figure out, but the hubby made a good point when we were discussing it last week (he’s pretty much in the same place I am when it comes to organized religion), that if we don’t bring him up with something in terms of a set of values, he’s more likely to be ripe-for-the-picking if he ever encounters a religious cult or fundamentalism when he’s older. That’s something I definitely don’t want. At the same time, I’m hesitant to “choose” a religion for our son or require him to go through the motions of adhering to a specific one, as I experienced growing up. (Going to church was not an option or a matter of choice in our house. So I went, and sort of pantomimed belief long after I’d give up on the faith I was raised in.)
And in American culture, it’s unavoidable. I can’t tell you how many times in the last four years, we’ve gotten religiously-themed presents for Parker; books about Jesus, Christian-themed toys, etc. I know they’re from well-meaning people who simply made assumptions that our family must be Christian (gay, liberal Christians, but Christians nonetheless, because what else would be be?), but it’s still rather awkward, because we end up making a serious effort not to offend, by not letting it show on our faces that it not “exactly what we wanted” for our son, and quietly setting it aside rather than figuring out a polite way of explaining that we don’t want our son getting those types of gifts. Instead, we quietly give them away.
But I can’t escape the feeling that something is unavoidably encroaching upon our family, it won’t go away if asked politely, and I’m not quite sure what to do about it.
In my mind I can’t help but think of it as a similar to the phenomenon of “compulsory heterosexuality” from my college days of studying queer theory for a semester.
Compulsory heterosexuality is the assumption that women and men are innately attracted to each other emotionally and sexually and that heterosexuality is normal and universal. This institutionalization of heterosexuality in our society leads to an institutionalized inequality of power not only between heterosexuals and non-heterosexuals, but also between men and women, with far reaching consequences.
Replace the terms dealing with sexual orientation with terms dealing with religious belief, and I think a case could be made for a kind of “compulsory Christianity” or “compulsory theism.” I’ve encountered it before, in the teacher who challenged my refusal to stand for the pledge of allegiance by saying “You can’t deny that there’s a God! Look at how many people believe it!” and years ago in my sister’s incredulity when I told her I considered myself a Buddhist as we were driving to the church she was attending then (she asked and I agreed to accompany her) and she placed her hand on her bible and said “You mean you don’t even read this any more? At all?” I mean, you just have to believe. Don’t you?
How do I say “No, I don’t,” and give my son the same freedom (that I didn’t have growing up), and still give him something to ground him when it comes to values about how he should treat other people and meet the world?
Thanks to a post by Nacho at Woodmoor Village, however, I may have found a helpful resource.
Traditionally, parenting resources for the task of raising humanist children have not been plentiful. Which is why I am glad to have found a wonderful new resource: Dale McGowan’s Parenting Beyond Belief: On Raising Ethical, Caring Kids Without Religion. Perfect title. The book is a collection of essays from various non-theists including Richard Dawkins, Julia Sweeney, Penn Jillete, Ed Bruckner, Tom Flynn, even Mark Twain, and other folks including a couple of reverends/ministers, and even the lovely mom from Agnostic Mom (check out her blog and column for Humanist News Network). The book site contains some rather nice resources, a forum, and other information. You can buy it from Amazon here (I don’t benefit at all from this so buy from whomever you prefer).
Check out the study guide, and the forums if you are interested in conversing with like-minded parents trying to do their best to, like us, practice parenting beyond religious belief. If you are one of those parents, raise your hand, let us know, and go post in the forum. What’s more, perhaps you can buy a copy of the book for the local library, or the school library, send a letter to the editor of a parenting magazine asking for a review of the book, post online about the book and your parenting, talk it up with friends… there are plenty of ways to contribute to making this perspective be seen through a better lens than the traditionally distorted lenses used for non-theists.
Oh boy am I ever “one of those parents.” I’ll be running to pick up a copy of Parenting Beyond Belief during my lunch break, passing it on to the hubby when I’m done with it, and checking out the website. For parents in our position it sounds, if you’ll pardon the pun, like a godsend.