The Republic of T.

Black. Gay. Father. Vegetarian. Buddhist. Liberal.

“Equal By Comparison” Is Not Equality

Jessica Valenti makes an excellent point about a common right-wing tactic for arguing against equality:

I’m wary of broadly painting Western women as universally less oppressed than others – there are actually many ways the US lags behind other countries on women’s rights, like political representation, corporate power and parental leave – but it is true that American women have more legal rights than women in some other countries. Saudi Arabia is the only country in the world where women aren’t allowed to drive. In Afghanistan, a woman can go to jail for leaving her abusive husband. Brazilian women can’t access abortions, nor can women in Ireland. According to a 2011 UN report, 127 countries don’t explicitly outlaw marital rape.
But is that really the standard by which people want to judge equality? So long as we have the right to vote, drive, go to school and work, American women should shut our mouths and be grateful to American men for allowing us to have that much?
The righteous fight for bare minimums doesn’t have much of a ring to it. The goal of feminism is justice – not to just be better off than other oppressed women. There’s no such thing as equal by comparison.

All out uganda infographic v4 9

This is very similar to a common argument against LGBT
Online Reputation Management equality in this country. I can’t count how many times I’ve had someone, usually a conservative opposed to LGBT equality in the US, say “You should go to so-and-so country, where those people are ‘really oppressed.’ Then you’d appreciate how good you have it here already.”

Mind you, now we know that this is often said by people who are involved in movements that export to other countries the kind of oppression they’d LIKE to impose on us back home. The draconian anti-gay laws in Russia and Uganada are prime examples of the role of the extreme religious right in the US directly influencing extreme anti-LGBT laws. So, they have a direct hand in creating the oppressive. (Uganda’s laws was recently struck down by the courts on technical grounds, leaving the door open for the country’s parliament to pass it again.)

Like Jessica Valenti said, righteous fight for bare minimums doesn’t have much of a ring to it. We’re not fighting just to be better off than people who are oppressed elsewhere. There is no such thing as equal-by-comparison.

It’s a common right-wing tactic to try and change the subject, by asking “Why aren’t you talking about this instead?” Usually “this” is something going on in another country. But I think with the laws in Russia and Uganda, we’ve see that fighting for equality isn’t an either/or question — as in either here at home, or some other country. 

(Via The Guardian World News)

Comments are closed.